The Supreme Court Overturns the Automatic Denial of Visas Based on Criminal Records for Relatives of Spanish Citizens

The Supreme Court has overturned one of the most controversial provisions of the new Immigration Regulations—the one that allowed for the automatic denial of residence permits to foreigners with Spanish family members simply because they had a criminal record. A ruling in response to an appeal filed by several social organizations now requires the government to review each case on an individual basis. In other words, whereas before you would simply receive a denial, now they have to take the time to examine your situation.

Until now, simply having a criminal record—and nothing else—was enough for them to say no. Well, the Supreme Court says that’s not good enough. From now on, if family rights or situations involving European citizens are at stake, the government will have to evaluate a number of factors: the severity of the crime, how much time has passed, your behavior since then, your family situation, the best interests of any minors… In short, it must demonstrate a real and current threat, not just a prior record.

But the ruling doesn’t stop there. It also overturns the ban that prevented married foreign minors from obtaining certain residence permits. The court argues that this restriction could harm victims of forced marriages. And it eliminates the requirement that child custody arrangements be established under Spanish law: Spain must recognize the rulings of other states when international conventions so require. Keep in mind, this is important for many people.

And there’s more: for temporary employment agencies, the Supreme Court overturns the ban that prevented them from hiring foreign nationals for seasonal work. It also declares it illegal to require people to interact with the government exclusively online—a measure that excluded those without digital access. A step forward, to be sure.

That said, it hasn’t overturned everything. The high court upholds other aspects of the regulation: for example, that asylum seekers cannot accumulate residency requirements while their application for international protection is pending, and that time spent in Spain while seeking asylum does not count toward certain residency requirements. So if you’re in that situation, keep that in mind.

If you’re applying for a residence permit through family reunification or as a relative of a Spanish citizen, this ruling directly affects you. The government can no longer deny your application solely because of a criminal record—though each case will be reviewed individually. So be sure to bring all documentation proving your reintegration into society and family ties. Be sure to stay well-informed.

If you’re having trouble with your appointment or the application process, message us on Telegram: https://t.me/cita_extranjeria